Last updated: November 1, 2026

Home values through September 30, 2026 (Zillow ZHVI) · listing trends September–October 2026 (Realtor.com) · closed sales through September 2026 (Redfin) · mortgage rates week of October 29, 2026 (Freddie Mac).

Fentress County’s market has stopped guessing and picked a direction: steady prices, more homes for sale, and more room to negotiate. The county’s typical home value sat at $243,554 on September 30, 2026 — +2.8% year over year and essentially flat month to month (−0.3%) — while active listings climbed to 499 homes, up 12.0% from a year ago. The median list price held near $375,000 (+11.2% YoY, −1.5% month over month) and the median days on market drifted up to 80 days. Realtor.com now classifies the county as a buyer’s market, with homes closing about 2.7% under asking.

The headline that will get repeated is the closed-sale median: Redfin has Fentress County at $329,163 for the three months ending September 2026, up 26.6% year over year. Don’t read that as a boom. With only about 25 closings a month, a handful of $500K–$900K sales moves the median hard. Zillow’s typical-value index, which measures the whole housing stock rather than one month’s closings, shows the county up a far more believable 2.8%. Realtor.com’s median sold price of $312,000 (+20.2% YoY) tells the same mix-driven story. The real trend is flat-to-low-single-digit appreciation, with rising inventory and longer marketing times.

Fentress County at a glance

ZIP-by-ZIP trends

ZIPCommunityTypical Value1-Yr ChangeMedian ListDays on MarketActive Listings
38556Jamestown$236,174 (Aug 2026)▲ +2.8%$375,200 (Oct) ▲ +16.1%88355
38553Clarkrange$275,000 (Aug 2026)▲ +5.5%$302,425 (Sep) ▲ +8.9%11323
38504Allardt$273,000 (Aug 2026)▲ +3.5%$299,000 (MLS, Nov 1)96–10237
38565Grimsley~$298,800 (AVM est.)—$389,450 (spring 2026)6218 ▼ −30%
38589Wilder$235,687 (Aug 2026)▼ −2.0%$65,500 (land-weighted)12779 (71 = land)

Sources: Zillow Home Value Index by ZIP (August 2026), Realtor.com ZIP-level market data (September–October 2026), East Tennessee REALTORS® MLS active listing counts (November 1, 2026). Grimsley and Wilder have too few annual closings for a reliable published 1-year index change; the Grimsley figure is an automated valuation, not a Zillow index. Wilder’s numbers are dominated by land: 71 of 79 active listings are acreage tracts and only 8 are houses, so treat its “median list price” as a land number, not a home price.

Reading the ZIPs: Jamestown (38556) carries the county’s inventory — 355 active listings and a median list of $375,200 that is 59% above the area’s typical home value. That gap is the single most useful number in this report: asking prices are still set high, and buyers are paying 94–97% of them. Clarkrange is the volume story of the month, with listings up 93% year over year and days on market more than doubling — a real shift toward buyers on the county’s west side. Allardt and Grimsley remain the premium addresses, and Grimsley’s inventory is down roughly 30% year over year, which is why its homes still move in about 62 days.

How Fentress compares: Crossville & Cumberland County

Cumberland County is the mirror image of Fentress right now. Redfin has Cumberland’s median sale price at $356,203 for the three months ending September 2026 — down 7.5% year over year — with 118 closings in September and 100 days on market. Zillow puts Crossville’s median sale price at $324,000 against a median list of $391,467, with 711 homes for sale and 62 days to pending. Crossville’s median list price has slipped 4.5% year over year to about $399,000.

On a typical-value basis, Cumberland’s $330,333 is roughly 36% above Fentress County’s $243,554. That gap is the whole pitch for this county: you buy roughly the same house, on more land, for about a third less — and Fentress values are rising (+2.8%) while Cumberland’s closed-sale median is falling. The trade-off is real: Crossville has the retail, the hospital, and 700+ listings to choose from. If you need amenities within five minutes, pay for Cumberland. If you want acreage, quiet, and the Big South Fork at the end of the road, Fentress is the value play in the Upper Cumberland.

Land market: Big South Fork & the Plateau

Acreage is where Fentress County’s market is most active — and most misread. Land.com currently shows 330 Fentress County listings totaling about 4,030 acres, a median list price of $392,000, and a median of $12,457 per acre, with a median 53 days on market. Redfin counts 196 land listings with a median of $369,000. Active MLS tracts as of November 1, 2026 show the spread clearly:

The rule of thumb holds: price per acre falls as tract size rises, and build-ready parcels (paved frontage, power at the road, a passing perc test) command a premium. Before you buy, verify legal access, soils for septic, and whether the parcel sits in Tennessee’s Greenbelt program — a rollback assessment can add thousands at closing.

What this means for buyers & sellers

Buyers: this is your window. Inventory is up 12% year over year, homes are taking 80 days at the median instead of 50–60, 17.7% of listings have already cut price, and not a single Fentress County sale closed above list price in September. Financing is the headwind: the 30-year fixed averaged 7.24% the week of October 29, 2026 — down from 7.40% mid-month but well above 6.17% a year ago. At 7.24%, the county’s typical $243,554 home carries about $1,660/month in principal and interest; a $375,000 listing runs about $2,556/month. Every eighth of a point matters — get a real pre-approval, not a pre-qualification, and consider a rate buydown funded by seller concessions, which are far easier to win in a 97%-of-list market than they were two years ago.

Sellers: the market has not crashed — values are still up 2.8% — but it has stopped paying for optimism. The county’s median list price ($375,000) sits 54% above the median sold price ($312,000) and 59% above the typical home value. That gap is not a signal that homes are worth more; it is a signal that a lot of listings are priced on hope. Homes that sell are closing at 94–97% of asking in 80–117 days. Price to the last three comparable closed sales — not to the listing down the street — and expect to negotiate on inspections and concessions.

The bottom line

Fentress County is a balanced-to-buyer’s market with stable values: +2.8% year over year on the typical home, 499 active listings (+12%), 80 median days on market, and closings at 97% of list. The dramatic closed-sale medians you’ll see quoted (+20% to +27%) are small-sample noise, not appreciation. Meanwhile Cumberland County’s median sale price is down 7.5% year over year while its typical value still sits 36% above Fentress — which is exactly why buyers who want land, privacy, and the Big South Fork keep landing here. With mortgage rates at 7.24% and negotiating room the best it has been in two years, motivated buyers have more leverage in Fentress County this month than at any point in 2026.

Thinking about buying or selling in Fentress County?
Get a free, no-obligation market analysis of your home or your target area.
Request your free market analysis →

Disclaimer: Data compiled from public sources including the Zillow Home Value Index (September 30, 2026 county and city; August 2026 by ZIP), Realtor.com Economic Research (September–October 2026), Redfin (three months ending September 2026), East Tennessee REALTORS® MLS active listing data (November 1, 2026), Land.com market insights, and the Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey (week ending October 29, 2026). Figures are for general information only, may be revised by the underlying sources, and are not a guarantee of value or performance. Fentress County transaction volume is small — roughly 25 closings a month — so medians can swing sharply on individual sales. Contact Team Denehy for current, listing-specific data.

tim@denehyhomes.com  ·  (931) 218-6606  ·  Jamestown, TN 38556